next up previous
Next: Hyperset Theory Up: ALTERNATIVE SET THEORIES Previous: ALTERNATIVE SET THEORIES

Admissible Set Theory

Admissible sets are formalized in a first order set theory called Kripke-Platek (KP) (Kripke 1964). Barwise weakened KP to a new theory KPU by readmitting the urelements (Barwise 1975). Urelements are the objects (or individuals) with no elements, i.e., they can occur on the left of , but not on the right. They are not considered in ZF because ZF is strong enough to live without them. But since KPU is a weak version of KP, Barwise decided to include them.

KPU is formulated in a first order language L with equality and with the membership symbol added. It has six axioms. The axioms of Extensionality and Foundation are about the basic nature of sets. The axioms Pair, Union, and - Separation (cf. Note 9) treat the principles of set construction. These five axioms can be taken as corresponding to ZF axioms of the same interpretation. The important axiom of - Collection assures that there are enough stages in the (hierarchical) construction process.

The universe of admissible sets over an arbitrary collection M of urelements is defined recursively:

where P is the power operation, and and are ordinals. This universe can be depicted as in Figure 3. It should be noticed that the KPU universe is like the ZF universe (excluding the existence of urelements), since it supports the same idea of cumulative hierarchy (Barwise 1977).

  
Figure 3: The universe of admissible sets (adapted from (Barwise 1975))

If M is a structure (cf. Note 10) for L, then an admissible set over M is a model of KPU of the form , where A is a nonempty set of non-urelements and is defined in . Such a typical admissible set over M can be depicted as in Figure 4. A pure admissible set is an admissible set with no urelements, i.e., it is a model of KP. Such a set can be depicted as in Figure 5.

  
Figure 4: A typical admissible set (adapted from (Barwise 1975))

  
Figure 5: A pure admissible set (adapted from (Barwise 1975))

KPU is an elegant theory which supports the concept of cumulative hierarchy and respects the principle of parsimony. (The latter claim will be proved in the sequel.) But it still cannot deal with self-reference because of its hierarchical nature.



next up previous
Next: Hyperset Theory Up: ALTERNATIVE SET THEORIES Previous: ALTERNATIVE SET THEORIES



Varol Akman
Sat Jan 13 15:54:04 EET 1996