NWG/RFC #295 JBP 2-JAN-72 15:35 8355 Protocol Workshop Report Report of the Protocol Workshop
By Jon Postel.
This is a report on the decisions reached at the protocol workshop held in conjunction with the Network Working Group meeting held in Cambridge from 10 to 14 October, 1971.
The workshop addressed itself to protocols of four types: IMP-Host, Host-Host, Initial Connection, and Process-Process.
The idea of IMP provided status reports to be exchanged via new IMP-Host protocol messages was discussed and rejected because it was felt that the level of state information which could be reported was not sufficient to be worth the trouble of implementing this mechanism.
The Host-Host Protocol was discussed and several problems were brought to light, among them were the following listed together with the group's recommendations.
The GVB - RET mechanism may prove useful sometime in the
future so it will be retained though no one appears to be
using it now, however spontaneous RET commands are
The ECO - ERP commands are useful and should be supported,
but spontaneous ERP commands are explicitly prohibited. A
further restriction is that a second ECO will not be sent
until the first ECO has been answered. Note that any of
the following may be an answer to an ECO: ERP, RST,
"Destination dead", or "Incomplete Transmission".
The RST - RRP commands are useful, but the proper use of these commands for determining the status of host software is still open for discussion (please direct comments to Jon Postel), however spontaneous RRP commands are explicitly prohibited.
The problem of unmatched CLS commands are discussed and four "solutions" were proposed:
Send a RST and clear the entry
Clear the entry and possibly mess up a future connection
Assign socket numbers in a sequential fashion to reduce the possibility of confusion and clear the entry.
Note that the first two suggestions follow the protocol while the last two do not.
The idea of flow control on the control link was suggested. A Request for Comments is to be prepared exploring this idea more fully.
The usefulness of the ERR command is compromised if the receiver mearly throws it out. Thus ERR's are to be logged, if at all possible, and checked out with the sending site.
The NCP document should make clear the implications of queueing or not queueing STR & RTS commands.
The Initial Connection Protocol (ICP) was discussed and found to be satisfactory however the following points were stressed:
The socket number sent by the logger (S) must be in
agreement with the socket numbers used in the STR & RTS sent by the logger.
The implications of queueing or not queueing of RTS & STR commands should be made clear in the ICP document. This is particularly important if the user chooses the "listen" option.
The Telnet committee has been reactivated to consider the following problems:
Clarification of the terminology half duplex, full duplex, character mode, line mode, ASCII, and echoing.
Clarification of the end of line convention. Especially to answer the question "Should there be a special end-of-line character?"
Clarification of the conditions for leaving Hide-your-input mode.
Clarification of the operation of Break and Synch.
Specification of a server-to-user Synch.
Clarification of the definition of the Network Virtual Terminal.
Preparation of a new document defining the Telnet protocol with the above improvements.
It is the servers option for disconnection to imply logout or not.
It is the servers option for logout to imply disconnection or not.
Extra characters used locally to fill the time for format
effectors to take effect should not be sent over the
Synch means to examine the data stream from the current
point to a data mark (x'80'). If any break type characters (e.g. etx, sub, Break) are found they are to have their
Upper and lower case are to be available to all Telnet users.
The Data and File Transfer Committee will report separately.
[ This RFC was put into machine readable form for entry ]
[ into the online RFC archives by BBN Corp. under the ] [ direction of Alex McKenzie. 12/96 ]